Requirements Verification and Validation for Product Teams

Chapters

Chapter 6: Requirements Verification and Validation for Product Teams

Chapters

Requirements Verification and Validation for Product Teams

The verification process ensures that software meets specifications. Validation focuses on whether the software meets the expectations and requirements of the end user.  

If you’re developing a medical device, this distinction may also be included in regulations and standards, for example:  

  • 820.30(f): Design verification shall confirm that the design output meets the design input requirements.
  • 820.30(g): Design validation shall ensure that devices conform to defined user needs and intended uses

If you’ve heard the terms “verification” and “validation” used interchangeably, you aren’t alone. However, this creates confusion during the testing process, and if you’re building products in highly regulated industries, it’s critical that products perform as expected and expensive errors are avoided. 

Unclear and incomplete requirements can be frustrating for developers, and if developers can’t get the required information upfront, they must make interpretations, which aren’t always correct. The result is a higher risk of errors and extra resources spent fixing issues further into the product development cycle. 

Understanding the difference between verification and validation and how to use each during product development helps reduce cost, increase efficiency and deliver a product that better fits user requirements. 

What is Requirements Verification?

This image shows a badge with a checkmark, portraying verification and validation

If you’ve used verification and validation interchangeably in the past, one of the most important things to note is the order. Software verification comes first, followed by validation. But what’s involved with each? Let’s dive into verification first. 

Verification tests check to ensure the program is built according to the stated requirements. The verification process includes activities such as reviewing the code and doing walkthroughs and inspections. 

Missing requirements or invalid requirements can be discovered during this phase, which can minimize the risk of rework and the cost associated with overruns. It’s far more effective to fix a small bug upfront than in the future when hundreds of lines of code must be identified and corrected. 

For example, imagine that you’re driving to a new destination. You might plug that destination into your GPS, which provides directions and the freeway exit number. If you’re looking for exit 10 and just passed exit 1, you quickly know you have nine more exits to go.  This is similar to the verification phrase in that using the GPS allows you to check your existing path against the directions. 

Another example is entering a formula into a spreadsheet. After entering a few rows of data, you might check the formula and make sure that it’s working. The process of verification is the same in that it allows you to do a quick check before getting too deep into the product development process.

What is Requirements Validation?

The answer to that question might vary depending on which industry you are in and which type of requirement is being validated.  

In general, after you’ve qualified what type of requirement is being validated and completed verification, it’s time to complete validation testing, which confirms the accuracy of the requirements. It ensures that the requirements have achieved the business objectives, meet the needs of any relevant stakeholders and are clearly understood by developers. Validation is a critical step to finding missing requirements and ensuring that requirements have a variety of important characteristics. Software validation addresses the following: 

  • Correctly outlines the end user’s need. 
  • Has only one exact meaning. 
  • Can be modified as necessary. 
  • Documents the attributes that customers truly need. 
  • Easily linked to system requirements, such as designs, codes and tests.
     

Validation isn’t focused on the path that you traveled to arrive at the destination but is instead focused on whether you’ve hit the mark. For example, consider the last example of a person traveling in a car and tracking landmarks, such as exit numbers. Let’s say the goal is to arrive at a hiking trail. A few questions might be asked when you arrive. 

  • Does the hiking trail look as expected? 
  • Can I see a marked trail and trailhead sign? 
  • Does the location meet my expectations? 

Validation is focused on the same types of questions. It’s not concerned with how you got there, but that you arrived at the correct location. 

If you’re designing a spreadsheet, as we discussed before, you checked that the formula worked during the verification process. During validation, you’re making sure the end product (the spreadsheet) meets the needs of the user. 

For example, using the spreadsheet example, maybe we determined we are going to use a spreadsheet to reduce the time it takes us to “x” or reduce the errors we see when we “y”, so we implement a spreadsheet with a bunch of functions, the functions defined by our requirements. Verification asks, does the spreadsheet work per the requirements (“did we build it right”); Validation asks, does the spreadsheet actually accomplish the goals related to x and y (“did we build the right thing”) 

And even when a product is fully verified – it still may not meet the needs of the user, i.e., failed validation.  

Why Teams Can Struggle With Requirement Validation

Requirement validation is frequently a stumbling block in complex product development. Teams often overlook this step or perform it far too late in the lifecycle, only realizing errors when a product fails to meet user needs or regulatory standards. While verification confirms technical accuracy, validation ensures you are solving the right problem. By combining rigorous validation with end-to-end traceability, organizations can confidently deliver systems that align with customer expectations and strict regulatory frameworks. This proactive approach transforms compliance from a chaotic burden into a competitive advantage.

Proactive Requirement Validation for Product Success

What is Requirement Validation and Traceability?

Requirement validation and traceability function as the verification mechanism for product success. While verification asks, “Did we build the product correctly based on specs?” validation asks, “Did we build the right product for the user?” Traceability connects these distinct phases, creating a clear line of sight from the initial stakeholder need to the final validation result.

Requirement validation and traceability ensure that each requirement is not only implemented correctly but also fulfills its intended business or regulatory need. Validation confirms that the product meets the user’s actual environment and usage needs, while traceability links specific requirements to test cases and results. Together, they provide clear proof that every requirement has been satisfied, reducing risk and supporting compliance. This continuous connection allows teams to detect disconnects between what was requested and what was built before they become expensive errors.

Why Validation Matters for Compliance and Quality

Validation is not just a technical checkpoint; it is a critical safeguard for quality and compliance. It ensures that the final output aligns with the original business intent rather than just the technical implementation. In highly regulated sectors, missing this step allows gaps where safety hazards or costly recalls can occur.

Validation proves critical across several key industries:

  • Medical Devices: Validation demonstrates that a device meets user needs and safety standards (like FDA and ISO 13485), directly reducing patient risk.
  • Aerospace and Defense: It ensures systems meet safety-critical regulations such as DO-178C, preventing catastrophic failures in complex environments.
  • Automotive: Teams rely on validation to meet ISO 26262 standards for functional safety, ensuring reliable performance in autonomous and assisted driving systems.

By prioritizing validation, these industries protect their liability and ensure that every delivered requirement serves a verified purpose.

Factors Contributing to Validation Success

Verification and Validation: What’s the Difference?

As you consider validation vs. verification, you might feel unsure about the differences. What activities fall under the category of validation and which fall under verification, and when should you perform each? 

Let’s say that you’re working to create a product and it’s time for verification testing since verification always comes first. During this process, you check documents, design, code, and the program to make sure the software is built according to requirements. The goal is to ensure the quality of the application or design. You might conduct activities such as reviews, walkthroughs or inspections. For example, in the Medical Device Industry, verification usually happens with the “design equivalent” configuration of the product. Validation usually happens with the “production equivalent” of the product per 820.30(g). 

Now, it’s time to move on to validation. During this process, you’re testing and validating whether the product meets the needs of your customer. Tasks in this process may include unit testing, integration testing or user testing. As we stated at the top of this article, the verification process ensures that software meets specifications. Validation focuses on whether the software meets the expectations and requirements of the end-user. 

Streamlining Collaboration During Verification and Validation With Requirements Management Software

For system engineers, being able to trace relationships between data types is essential. However, there can be a problem with multiple levels of requirements, specification, and verification artifacts all having their own set of stakeholders who are performing a variety of tasks.

The right software solution can simplify complicated situations and enable you to add traceability of the data. You can analyze the “who, what, where, and why” of potential changes and make sure that essential data doesn’t get overlooked. Look for a software solution that does the following:

  • Connects test cases from a problem statement to your requirements and design. If you don’t have the ability to do this, you can’t be sure that you haven’t overlooked something critical.
  • Connects system requirements to business and stakeholder requirements. If you miss a critical connection, you risk unplanned expenses that may have a ripple effect and create slowdowns in product launches, weaken stakeholder confidence and adversely affect the bottom line.
  • Improves decomposition. It’s critical to relate lower-level requirements to higher-level requirements to ensure that components and subcomponents all come together into a functional system. Mistakes in this area may lead to extra costs as you work hard to put the pieces back together and implement changes later in the product development process.

A software solution is a critical tool in helping you manage the V&V process and ensure that every engineering activity is connected throughout the entire system life cycle. It’s critical to capture all communication in context and bring stakeholders together in one place for a real-time and comprehensive look into what teams are building and why.

How Live Traceability™ Supports Validation Success

Validation is most effective when requirements are continuously tracked against test results. As part of Jama Connect®, Live Traceability supports validation success by automating the links between requirements, test cases, and validation results. Instead of relying on static spreadsheets or documents that quickly become outdated, Live Traceability creates a dynamic, living data model.

This approach provides real-time evidence of compliance. If a test fails or a requirement changes, the system flags the impact immediately across the entire development chain. Teams can instantly generate audit-ready reports that demonstrate every requirement has been validated. This automation reduces the risk of human oversight and ensures that no requirement is validated in isolation. Product, engineering, and QA teams share a single source of truth, enabling them to catch issues early and maintain a state of constant audit readiness.

By integrating requirement validation with Live Traceability, teams move from reactive firefighting to proactive quality management. This ensures products are safe, compliant, and market-ready.

In This Webinar, We Discuss Jama Connect® vs IBM® DOORS® for Requirements-Driven Testing

DEFINITION OF VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION:

Verification and Validation (V&V) are independent procedures that are used together for checking that a product, service, or system meets requirements and specifications and that it fulfills its intended purpose. These are critical components of a quality management system such as ISO 9000. The words “verification” and “validation” are sometimes preceded with “independent”, indicating that the verification and validation is to be performed by a disinterested third party. “Independent verification and validation” can be abbreviated as “IV&V”.

Book a Demo

See Jama Connect in Action!

Our Jama Connect experts are ready to guide you through a personalized demo, answer your questions, and show you how Jama Connect can help you identify risks, improve cross-team collaboration, and drive faster time to market.